How should we respond to the public mistakes and shortcomings of Christian leaders?
This is the question that over the last 48 hours the Streaming Faith management team wrestled with as we sought to formulate an appropriate response to the tragic situation concerning Juanita Bynum and Bishop Thomas Weeks. This story is being reported on virtually every secular news outlet in the world. Some covering the story could barely contain their glee at the misfortunes of these high profile Christian leaders.
It was obvious to us that many of our colleagues in Christian media were also wrestling with how to handle this story, as they, too, refrained from publishing articles or commentary about the situation right away. Sadly, there were several Christian media outlets who chose to reprint the words of the secular media word for word. Some added a subheading saying we need to pray for those involved - and then preceded to report all of the juicy, gory details. Their approach is reminiscent of carnal church members we have all known who under the guise of sharing a "prayer request" engage in gossip, which is repulsive to God and damaging to the Body of Christ. (Read Proverbs 16:28, and Romans 1:29)
Seemingly adding insult to injury, last night news broke of yet another prominent Christian couple who had announced they were seeking a divorce.
So how should we as believers respond when faced with the public shortcomings of Christian leaders? Let me suggest four ways you can be a part of the solution and not a part of the problem:
1. Pray about it more than you talk about it. Henry Blackaby once told me that virtually every church he's visited spends at least twice as long talking about prayer in their services as they do actually praying. I was shocked when he told me that, but then I realized that many times I am guilty of the same thing in my personal life. How often do I assure someone I will pray for them and then forget to pray? How often do I talk about a situation but neglect to pray about it?
In the wake of multiple revelations about marital problems with high profile Christian leaders, Bishop Donald Hilliard from Cathedral International in New Jersey is calling the church to prayer. In a statement released yesterday he said: "Let us pray that the church of Christ continues to be the salt of the earth and the light of the world in spite of what may seem to be glaring inconsistencies among the saints... My prayer is that we walk in peace and love, forgive each other, love each other and yet at the same time try to help each other so that the body of Christ will not be shamed."
"This is not the time to throw stones, but rather stand together and show the world that we walk together in love," Hilliard said.
2. Recognize that Christian leaders are human, too. In America, we have created a celebrity culture around prominent pastors and Christian leaders. The effect of this has been to greatly intensify the "pedestal" effect and "fishbowl" existence that every Christian leader - from local church pastor to internationally known evangelist - experiences to some degree or another. We cast them as perfect in every way, and they have to try and maintain that image to keep their ministry and influence. When was the last time you heard a prominent Christian share about the areas they struggle with and transparently ask for prayer in that area? The answer is probably never. To admit struggles and seek prayer support or accountability would be to admit they aren't what we try to pretend that they are.
There has only been one Person who lived a spotless life and who never sinned when tempted, and that is the Lord Jesus. Our leaders are sinners saved by grace just like you and me.
I heard the story about two wise sisters in Christ who were approached by the church gossip attempting to run down the pastor. They wouldn't give her the time of day. Finally the gossip asked one of them, "So what do you think about the preacher?" The wise saint responded, "Honey, all I know is that the Lord can shake a mighty lick with a crooked stick!"
The truth is we are all "crooked sticks." If we waited until we were perfect to share the Good News of the Gospel, no one would ever get saved. We are like the Pharisees standing near the woman with rocks in our hands. When Jesus invited those without sin to throw stones at her, one by one they walked away as God convicted them of the sin in their lives.
3. Be aware you do not know the whole story. For some of us the only exercise we get is jumping to conclusions! The only people who know the whole story in a situation like this are the two people directly involved. At best we know part of the story and that part may or may not be one-sided. Wise people resist rushing to judgment based on what you hear in the news or from the "grapevine."
4. Be a Friend. If God has allowed you to be a friend to your pastor or any other church leader, you have been given a wonderful opportunity for genuine ministry. The more prominent and well-known the pastor or leader is, the more "hangers on" he or she will have surrounding them. Most of these people are not friends, but leeches who want only to use their access to this person for their own gain or self interest. People who are true friends are those who will listen to you, pray with you and for you, hold you accountable, and allow you to honestly share your hurts, your pain, your struggles.
I can tell you from personal experience when you are involved in public ministry, friends like this are rare and more precious than gold. If God has allowed you to be a friend to a leader, be there for them through thick and thin. Love them for who they are, not what they can do for you.
There is something about our fallen nature that draws us to the misfortunes of others. Traffic snarls around a wreck because of gawkers, and supermarket tabloids make millions exploiting gossip. But God has called His people to rise above that.
Finally, brethren, whatever things are true, whatever things are noble, whatever things are just, whatever things are pure, whatever things are lovely, whatever things are of good report, if there is any virtue and if there is anything praiseworthy — think on these things. Philippians 4:8 (NKJV)